Beauty,  Lipsticks Lipliners and Lipglosses,  Wake up and Makeup

REVIEW: Benefit Precisely my Brow 3.5 vs Goof Proof Brow Pencil

I LOOOOOOOOOOOOOOVE Benefit Cosmetics’ eyebrow makeup line. This is their forte and they’re living up to it. There’s an eye makeup for every type of brows us boys and girls have. Thin, sparse, thick, messy, you name it they have it! 

I’ve reviewed their Goof Proof Pencil before and I liked it a lot. I wanted to try something else and their SA recommended me their Precisely My Brow (P1,400) afer I had my brows waxed. Let’s see if this is any better, same, or worse.

What’s my brow type? KALAT or messy in english. I’m blessed to have a generous amount of hair, but all over the place with thin strands. Take a look at my makeup-free brows below:




Benefit Precisely my Brows

*Description from BeautyMNL

A dual-ended pencil with an ultra fine tip that easily defines the brows with hair-like strokes. 

Draws, shapes, and shades brows with precision; rich, blendable color delivers a natural look; waterproof, budge-proof formula provides 12-hour wear; twist-up tip requires no sharpener; built-in spoolie blends color and combs strands for a groomed look; winner of Glamour 2017 Beauty Award for Best Brow Product






Goof Proof vs Precisely My Brow

Kikaysikat Says: Photos on Goof Proof is significantly better because it was shot on a better lighting and a better mirrorless camera (Fuji XA2) that I sold off, because it was a gift from my boyfirend, and we broke up, and now we’re back together again. I regret selling my camera.


WRONG COLOR. I should’ve followed my heart and gotten Shade #3 which is a medium brown color. 3.5 is more medium ash-brown that makes my dull eyebrows gray. Ugh…. Now I have to finish this off by using it everyday even when I’m at home just so I don’t waste money.

Okay now that I let out my rant from the color I picked, let’s continue with reviewing the product itself. It comes in a sleek silver pencil that holds .08 grams of product. That’s minuscule I know. 


It creates the most natural looking hair strokes and it lasts a good 8-12 hours. Even when I brush it with the built-in spoolie, it doesn’t smudge or fade unevenly. 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.